Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Thoughts @ 4AM!

I just can't sleep. There are so many things thats coming to my mind, so here I am, at 4AM typing them out for you. I have made streams of thoughts revolving around one core area but before that I have put down the conclusion questions for those who dont want to read the streams (I urge you to read it though, atleast that part that is you with respect to me)


I would like to ask:


1) Are we so scared or irresponsible that we don't want to protect and stand up for the very land that we live, earn, eat and drink from?

2) Are we really "The Indian Crab", who dont want all to progress together but are more keen on bringing down other's progress or being so selfish that only we want to progress? If yes, do we want to continue to be them despite knowing it?

3)Are rational thinking and human nature to adapt and accept, washed out from us, that the land we live in is not our's, but the land we left behind is always the one we protect?

4) Are we not able to see "IT" as a means of getting this Nation to be one strong county but we use it to make it more divided and make the divide stand out more starkly!


A reply to a different argument:


Situation is the Cauvery water dispute. A friend of mine, a tamil settled in Karnataka, asked, what if all the tamilians in Bangalore boycott offices - His complaint was about not getting tamil TV channels - and prove to the Government of their influence and presence.

My reply:
Boycott offices but go say "We too live in Karnataka, this is our home now, we use the water from here, this land's growth matters to us, justice to this place is our right, be just and come to a fair decision - to our land - the land that is sharing it's waters freely over so many decades. Give it something back for giving you the lifeline of precious water instead of just being more greedy". It's time for you all who live in this place, to call this place your home and stand up to protect it. Else, there might come a time when the water and money is all gone and just like the gardens are gone from the garden city, the people might too from the city...

The water from Karnataka gave Tamilnadu the lifeline, just like a mother's blood gave life to the child in the womb, like a friend's help revived a weak one. It's time the child and friend to grows up and becomes self sufficient, time to protect the Mother instead of just gnashing at the womb for more blood. Time to become a responsible child than to just become a arrogant mindless brat. (In my own personification.) Time to stop asking for more free help and instead get to be self reliant and repay with gratification.


The thought streams are here:



Stream1 - My Family:


At a function, 4 generations of the family - grandparents, parents, us and the next generation. There is a constant stream of talk, switching between kannada and Telgu effortlessly. In the 200 or so people about 3 grandparents and one entire sub-family (father, mother, children - a new addition to our family by marriage) can't speak Kannada. Most of us are good enough in Kannada to completely express ourselves - from screaming to sweet talking. Some have gone further and have studied this language with Masters and PhDs. Ofcorse, Telgu is not forgotten but happily intersperced in the conversation. It's an easy switchover, infact so easy, that till now we have not seen them as seperate languages, or that I am supposed to be partial to Telgu or Kannada. For us, both are mother tongues. Afterall, we live here and we use all this land's resources and that empowers us to say, THIS IS MY CULTURE TOO!


Stream2 - My Office:


At work we are a mixed crowd. There are Mallus, Tamils, Telgus, Northies and a couple of us Kannadigas. The outsiders plan to stay here for upwards of a decade atleast if not more. Strangely, only 1 person in that set is making a concious effort to inculcate this culture and calls bangalore her Home. It feels as if everyone else has an aversion to Karnataka and it's culture. It's looked upon almost as a criminal offence to absorb this culture. There are almost 70% outsiders in my team, they come here to bangalore, use all the infrastructure available and never once want to call it their place. Never once care to make a difference. They prefer to remain outsiders living inside. How can one expect to be accepted and united if such is the mindset? Whatever happened to the responsibility to the land that gives one the food he eats, the water that he drinks and the space to live in? Is this mind block fair? Human? Why blame someone when there is bias in one's own self?


Stream3 - My Friends:


I have friends who are kannadigas as well as those who have moved here for work. Those who have moved in have built houses here, have families here. Most also know the local language and culture. There are also those who are otherwise too. Those who isolate themselves behind the shut doors of their homes and tele-port back to "their" land from within their tele-visions. Those to whom it hardly matters what happens to the land they live in. They come out only to brashly point fingers at everyone else when something happes to their comforts but never to live with the locals. It pains that most of them are people who don't want to know about the local culture, who's families are not known to each other and they have not grown to become a tight bond but have remained - just friends. Gone are days of "aunty's coffee and snacks", "the parents' talks and gossips", "the sit at home, with the family and talk", I dont know their family and they dont know me; ofcorse the families don't knowing each other at all. Sometimes it's 'cause of language barrier, but more often it's a person's own barrier. Thanks to those few with whom I have bonded and not just remained friends.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

Wow....

Your thoughts are pretty serious!

Usha gave the link to your blog.

Time each one of us went into introspection about this. we may be faced with a lot of hard reality that we have been happily ignoring so far.

Sundar said...

Glad you got the idea behind the post and didn't get lost in kannada-Tamil war zone :-)

Anonymous said...

Need to go beyond the language zone...this is just not about Karnataka or Tamil Nadu, but about retaining our identity.

I think we have some similar thoughts, good to see someone else also thinking along same lines.

Sundar said...

Good to hear these words. Most people made the wrong assuptions here.

Anonymous said...

It' true that we outsiders stay in this place and use the resources.But why not think of us as Indians rather calling us as outsiders.Of course we all are from the same country.Yes,we came here to work.Doesn't mean that we have to totally forget the place from where we've come and call this as our place.I'm sure that any kannadiga who moves from Karnataka to TamilNadu or even any other place in India would never call that new place as his hometown just because he has come there to work and he would definitely like his hometown because it's the place where he has been born and broughtup.I've been in Bangalore for almost 3 years.I don't have anything against Karnataka but still I think these kind of thoughts whether to call the new place as hometown or not should come within oneself.You cannot simply force people to call this place their hometown just because people work here.

About the Cauvery dispute, why can't the mother be a little humane to the child? True, that they blocked all the TV channels ,this is not something very serious.But what about the transport?? Public transport was blocked, all couriers from TN did not reach Karnataka for more than a week.They blocked Shatabdhi Express.What If anyone have to travel urgently?? It was almost like the independence of tamilians was totally blocked.My personal experience, I had to receive an important courier urgently but had to wait for it for more than a week.And also we were warned not to talk in Tamil outside.So the total freedom of us was lost.Inspite of the mother doing all this how can you expect the child to have affinity towards the mother??

I rather would not call Karnataka and TN mother and child because its meaningless!

Sundar said...

Ok! Lemme go point by point here.

1)This is not about karnataka and tamilnadu but an example taken of people moving from one place to another.

2)No one said forget, what was said was that adopt the other culture ALSO!

3)Outsiders and Insiders does not mean anything offensive here. It means people living here and people who have come from other places to here. I am shocked to see the mis-interpretation

4)We have a word "Birth Place", use that. Home town is where you have your home where you are living. People work to earn, earn to live and enjoy life, so why not have the feeling towards the place. I don't really think it's so hard to love the place you live in. Try it, it will make your life much happier :-)

5)Regarding transport, it was not only tamilians but any traveller including kannadigas who were affected. Same applies to other points related. No one said bandh is good or blocking TV channels is good. What was said was to fight for a justice. Instead of fearing, how about joining in the cause of providing justice? may be your presence in the bandh might have made more of an impact, to the cause as well as to your living here. Imagine how much more you would be respected for standing up for justice!

6)Ok last point accepted. That was a bad comparision and a statement made with emotion rather than thought.

Phoenix said...

Well... I appreciate your concerns!!!
But I'd would also like to explain some facts that we usually forget conveniently. Before the two dams across the cauvery were built, water was surplus for Tamilnadu. Karnataka government wanted to build a dam and for that to happen they needed to get approval of all other states where the cauvery extends itself. They agreed to send enough water(triple times of what the tribunal ordered karnataka to send)to Tamilnadu. But soon, without approval of other states karnataka government had built one more dam and many small ones too. This almost gradually stopped the water supply to tamilnadu(comparatively). It has become a common practice to drain water to TamilNadu only at the time of flood(no other go, else dam would break eventually).
I'm not blaming any state entirely, it's common that each state focus only on their development. But beyond states, we should also think that we are one nation. Development through out the nation is important than one specific green. Known persons would accept that it was politicians who cooked up this issue and used this for their own success both in tamilnadu and karnataka.
I have many friends who are kannadikkas who know these facts, agree to this.
I love my country and I love each part of my country and my country men.
Machi, I'm still ur friend!!! :)

Phoenix said...

I agree with you that, we need to have love and care for the place that gives us life... In 'God of small Things' Arundhathi Roy had brilliantly expressed the love for lifeless things around us.
We share common idea about this.

Sundar said...

Glad you have similar opinion on loving the place we live in too.

The water issue, Dams and the likes are a reality as such; as is the fact that a lot of people from all over the country are migrating to Bangalore and the city's needs has grown to such a large extent that water has to be reduced to TN. There is more rain in K and less in TN. So instead of making it a free water supply, make it a Economic move. A barter system, TN gives something back to K for the water it gets from K.
Anyway, this was discussed in
http://placidsun.blogspot.com/2007/02/water-woes.html
and I got no comments there. :-)

Srik said...

Very absorbing!!

I second Vani's thoughts about facing the hard reality.

There are some "outsiders" who remain outsiders even if they live for decades here!! They choose to do so. I have seen a few of my "friends" behaving so, sadly.

Forget adopting the culture, they dont make any attempt to know it, not even an inch. That pains actually.

We might have to change the title "Be a Roman in Rome" to "Make Rome everywhere if you are a Roman"

Srik said...

BTW,
Usha linked me here :D

Sundar said...

welcome! :-)

may be we need to start putting that idea to such people. may be they still have not realised it :-)

Wild Reeds said...

Hey Sundar
Neat blog
Cheers
Wild Reeds

Sundar said...

Merci! :-)